A Guide to Predatory Journals

Written by Dr Katrin Frisch, 2026 (first version 2024). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20441390

This guide is available in German and English via Zenodo.

Introduction

Predatory Journals are profit-oriented publishing venues that pretend to be academic publishers with professional quality standards. In reality, they publish content without (proper) peer review in exchange for payment. According to Grudniewicz et al. (2019) they ‘are characterized by false or misleading information, deviation from best editorial and publication practices, a lack of transparency, and/or the use of aggressive and indiscriminate solicitation practices’ (p. 211). A special subtype of predatory journals are the so-called hijacked journals (see below).

An official list of predatory journals does not exist, and there are significant debates within research communities which journals should be subsumed under this label. The term and the concept itself are also subjects of debate: for instance, the term “predatory journal” implies that these journals exploit researchers’ lack of knowledge or unfamiliarity with the publication system. However, studies highlight another facet of the phenomenon, namely, that researchers knowingly publish in predatory journals/publishers (see Frandsen 2018).

A major criticism of the concept “predatory journal” is that it encompasses a wide spectrum of different types of journals; as a result, legitimate but low-quality journals are grouped alongside journals with clear deceptive intent (i.e. fake journals). It is argued that it would be more effective to focus on predatory practices instead and to evaluate all journals and publishers accordingly (see IAP 2022). However, the focus of this guide is not the theoretical debate surrounding predatory journals, but how to handle them in practice.

As a general rule, researchers should not publish their results in predatory journals, and certainly not intentionally. Predatory journals not only falsely claim to adhere to scientific quality standards; articles published in them are also harder to find, as they are often not indexed by literature databases (Kurt 2018; however, more recent studies show that predatory journals are sometimes listed, see Macháček/Srholec 2022[1] using the example of Scopus).

Precisely because a clear identification of predatory journals and publishers is not always possible and the same journal may be viewed differently depending on a researcher’s status group, research community or individual experience (see the MDPI example below), researchers in leadership positions in particular should provide guidance to early-career researchers on which journals are relevant within a specific research community.
 

Choice of Publication Outlet

Researchers should carefully select the publication outlet for their own work. Talking to peers can be helpful in finding a suitable journal. Predatory journals are often characterized by misleading information, intrusive solicitation, and (claims of) extremely short timeframes from article submission to publication. Furthermore, promises of prioritized handling of submitted manuscripts should be viewed critically and can be seen as an indication of an untrustworthy publication outlet. The amount of article processing charges (APC), however, is not a reliable indicator that a journal is predatory.

Additionally there are a number of guides and recommendations to help researchers identify predatory journals. The so-called ‘Beall’s List’ (originally created by the American librarian Jeffrey Beall, who also coined the term ‘predatory journal’) is the most well-known collection of predatory journals. However, he has not updated it since 2017, and for this and other reasons, it is not necessarily recommended to use it (see, e.g., Swauger 2017). There are also paid services, for example the company Cabells provides a database called ‘Predatory Reports’. Researchers should note that all existing lists of predatory journals/publishers make use of different criteria and thus differ in their assessments (see also Grudniewicz et al. 2019). Therefore, a blacklist should not be used as the sole point of reference for evaluating a journal or publisher.

Researchers can also check whether the publisher in question is a member of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) or whether the Open Access journal in question is listed in the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ). However, the mere listing of a journal/publisher is not necessarily a sufficient indicator of trustworthiness, as some predatory journals appear to meet the standards by imitating reputable journals or by operating in a grey area.

In questionable cases, it is therefore necessary to check the journal or publisher for specific details. For example, the journal/publisher’s website should display all important information regarding the publication process, publication costs, details about the Editorial Board, and editorial policies. The Think.Check.Submit. checklist, which compiles information for evaluating a journal, can serve as a helpful tool. Library staff and employees of Open Access funding offices can also be helpful in assessing journals and publishers.

However, some journals and publishers have been a subject of debate on this matter for quite some time. What makes an assessment very difficult in this case, is that the publication practices of these outlets are perceived very differently across various disciplines. A survey conducted at the University of Kassel illustrated these differing assessments using the publisher MDPI as an example (Pohlmann 2023).

Hijacked Journals

In addition, there is the phenomenon of so-called “hijacked journals.” These are websites that imitate prestigious journals, for example, by using the same ISSN, the same name, or a slightly modified name (see Hegedűs et al. 2024). In some cases, they also copy other information from the original journal. It is possible that despite adopting the name and ISSN, the scope of the hijacked journal completely differs from the original journal (for example, the German journal for the language and culture of the deaf, Das Zeichen, becomes a specialist journal for “Engineering & Technology” on the website of the hijacked Zeichen Journal, which uses the same ISSN). In this way, hijacked journals, even if they target completely different (disciplinary) audiences, can use the ISSN of the original journal to pretend that they are listed in databases such as Scopus or Web of Science.

Researchers should carefully scrutinize journals that are unknown to them. Irregularities and conflicting information on the website can be strong indicators that a journal has been hijacked. For instance, the hijacked journal Diagnosis lists articles in “its” back issues that were taken from other journals. The corresponding abstracts do not match the content of the cited titles, and in some cases, the same abstract is used for multiple articles (so-called “fictitious archives,” see Abalkina 2021). The price for downloading an article is $200. All of this makes it clear that this is not a legitimate journal. The hijacked journal Research copied almost all website information (name, ISSN, “About” section, Editorial Board) verbatim from the legitimate journal Research; however, for a journal in the field of life and natural sciences, it contains a conspicuously high number of contributions from the humanities.

The Hijacked Journal Checker provided by Retraction Watch and created by Abalkina can also be helpful. Lists of titles can also be found in the research literature on the subject (e.g., Abalkina 2023, Jalalian and Dadkhah 2015). Since developments in this field are dynamic, multiple criteria should always be applied when evaluating journals.

Assessing articles published in predatory journals

Researchers should critically examine journals during their literature review. However, the publication venue is not a decisive criterion for the quality of an individual article. Therefore, the assessment of scholarly articles should not be made dependent on the publication venue alone. Researchers must decide on a case-by-case basis, particularly in the context of meta-analyses, whether articles from predatory journals should be included, cited, or referenced in their own projects and publications. In some cases, it might be helpful to address the issue in the respective paper and explain the decision for or against the use or inclusion of certain articles.

Articles that are published in predatory journals as part of a cumulative dissertation may entail repercussions in accordance with examination regulations (Prüfungsordnung). In such cases, it is questionable whether the necessary qualification requirements – the publication of articles in peer-reviewed journals – have been met. If individual researchers frequently publish in proven predatory journals and this becomes apparent, for example, in grant applications or in the context of competing for performance-based funding (LOM), this could be taken into account in the evaluation. It may be necessary to determine whether such a practice (especially if it occurs repeatedly and against better judgment) violates Guideline 15 of the DFG Code of Conduct, “Guidelines for Safeguarding Good Research Practice.”

Predatory Conferences

Another problem in academia is the growing market of predatory conferences, events that, much like predatory journals, are characterized by a lack of scientific quality standards. Predatory conferences can take various forms, ranging from poorly organized events that deviate significantly from their announcements to outright fraudulent schemes where no conference takes place at all despite high registration fees. Similar to predatory journals, researchers should pay close attention to quality standards when choosing conferences and should be particularly critical of invitations from organizations unknown to them.

Reputable conferences usually provide transparent information on their website regarding the organizer, the venue, deadlines, and fees. If this is not the case, researchers should scrutinize the conference website carefully before deciding to participate or submit a paper. In particular, early-career researchers should seek advice from their peers and established colleagues if they harbour suspicions or feel uncertain about the legitimacy of a conference announcement or invitation. Researchers can find further resources on the topic of predatory conferences in the checklist Think.Check.Attend.

Bibliography

Abalkina, Anna (2021). Detecting a network of hijacked journals by its archive. Scientometrics 126; S. 7123-7148. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-021-04056-0

Abalkina, Anna (2024). Challenges posed by hijacked journals in Scopus. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 75(4); S. 395-422. https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.24855

Abramo, Giovanni; Aguillo, Isidro F.; Aksnes, Dag W.; Boyack, Kevin; Burrell, Quentin L.; Campanario, Juan Miguel; Chinchilla-Rodríguez, Zaida; Costas, Rodrigo; D’Angelo, Ciriaco Andrea; Harzing, Anne-Wil; Jamali, Hamid R.; Larivière, Vincent; Leydesdorff, Loet; Luwel, Marc; Martin, Ben; Mayr, Philipp; McCain, Katherine W.; Peters, Isabella; Rafols, Ismael; Robinson-Garcia, Nicolas; Schubert, Torben; Small, Henry; Sugimoto, Cassidy R.; Thelwall, Mike; van den Besselaar, Peter; van Leeuwen, Thed and Waltman, Ludo (2022). Retraction of “Predatory publishing in Scopus: evidence on cross-country differences” lacks justification. Scientometrics 128, 1459–1461. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-022-04565-6

Beall, Jeffrey (2017). What I learned from predatory publishers. Biochemia Medica, 27(2); S. 273-278. https://doi.org/10.11613/BM.2017.029.

Dony, Christophe; Raskinet, Maurane; Renaville, François; Simon, Stéphanie and Thirion, Paul (2020). How Reliable and Useful Is Cabell’s Blacklist? A Data-Driven Analysis. LIBER Quarterly: The Journal of the Association of European Research Libraries 30 (1); S. 1-38. https://doi.org/10.18352/lq.10339

Frandsen, Tove Faber (2019). Why do researchers decide to publish in questionable journals? A review of the literature. Learned Publishing, Vol 32; S. 57-62.  https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/leap.1214

Grudniewicz, Agnes; Moher, David; Cobey, Kelly D.; Bryson, Gregory L.; Cukier, Samantha; Allen, Kristiann; Ardern, Clare; Balcom, Lesley; Barros, Tiago; Berger, Monica; Ciro, Jairo Buitrago; Cugusi, Lucia; Donaldson, Michael R.; Egger, Matthias; Graham, Ian D.; Hodgkinson, Matt; Khan, Karim M.; Mabizela, Mahlubi; Manca, Andrea; Milzow, Katrin; Mouton, Johann; Muchenje, Marvelous; Olijhoek, Tom; Ommaya, Alexander; Patwardhan, Bhushan; Poff, Deborah; Proulx, Laurie; Rodger, Marc; Severin, Anna; Strinzel, Michaela; Sylos-Labini, Mauro; Tamblyn, Robyn; van Niekerk, Marthie; Wicherts, Jelte M. and Lalu, Manoj M (2019). “Predatory Journals: No Definition, No Defence; Nature, Vol 576, S. 210-212. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-019-03759-y

Hegedűs, Mihály; Dadkhah, Mehdi and Dávid, Lóránt D. (2024). Masquerade of authority: hijacked journals are gaining more credibility than original ones. Diagnosis, vol. 11, no. 3; S. 235-239. https://doi.org/10.1515/dx-2024-0082

Jalalian, Mherdad and Dadkhah, Mehdi (2015). The full story of 90 hijacked journals from August 2011 to June 2015. Geographica Pannonica, 19(2), 73-87. https://doi.org/10.18421/GP19.02-06

Kurt, Serhat (2018). Why do authors publish in predatory journals? Learned Publishing, 31: S. 141-147. https://doi.org/10.1002/leap.1150

Macháček, Vít and Srholec, Martin (2022). Predatory publishing in Scopus: Evidence on cross-country differences. Quantitative Science Studies 3 (3); S. 859–887. https://doi.org/10.1162/qss_a_00213

Moher, David; Shamseer, Larissa; Cobey, Kelly D.; Lalu, Manoj M.; Galipeau, James; Avey, Marc T.; Ahmadzai, Nadera; Alabousi, Mostafa; Barbeau, Pauline; Beck, Andrew; Daniel, Raymond; Frank, Robert; Ghannad, Mona; Hamel, Candyce; Hersi, Mona; Hutton, Brian; Isupov, Inga; McGrath, Trevor A.; McInnes, Matthew D. F.; Page, Matthew J.; Pratt, Misty; Pussegoda, Kusala; Shea, Beverley; Srivastava, Anubhav; Stevens, Adrienne; Thavorn, Kednapa; van Katwyk, Sasha; Ward, Roxanne; Wolfe, Dianna; Yazdi, Fatemeh; Yu, Ashley M. and Ziai, Hedyeh (2017). Stop this Waste of People, Animals and Money. Nature, Vol 549; S. 23-25. https://doi.org/10.1038/549023a

Pohlmann, Tobias (2023). Auswertung einer Umfrage zur Wahrnehmung des Open-Access-Verlags MDPI an der Universität Kassel. https://doi.org/10.17170/kobra-202304057786

Ro, Christine (2024); How to Spot a Predatory Conference. Nature, Vol 632; S. 219-220.  https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-02360-2

Swauger, Shea (2017). Open Access, power, and privilege: A response to “What I learned from predatory publishing.” College & Research Libraries News, 78(11); S. 603-606. https://doi.org/10.5860/crln.78.11.603 The InterAcademy Partnership (IAP) (2022). Combatting Predatory Academic Journals and Conferences. https://www.interacademies.org/publication/predatory-practices-report-English


[1] The study by Macháček/Srholec 2022 was originally published in Scientometrics in 2021, but retracted by the editor-in-chief following an objection by Frontiers, complaining about the article’s reliance on Beall’s List, as well as due to criticism from the post-publication peer review. After revision, it was republished in Quantitative Science Studies. The initial retraction was subject of another article in Scientometrics, whose authors – some of them members of the Review Board – criticised the decision (Abramo et al. 2022).

Photo by Yaroslav Zotov via Unsplash